Course: High-redshift
galaxies in the HDF and elsewhere
Prof. Mark E. Dickinson
Space Telescope Science Institute
(STScI)
EEUU

IR image of the HDF.
Courtesy of Huble Space Telescope, NICMOS and STIS
Systematic redshift surveys
of large numbers of galaxies are producing an increasingly good picture of galaxy
evolution at high redshift, that is, of the early Universe. The analysis of the Hubble
Deep Field (HDF) data has largely contributed to this scenario. The HDF images have been
produced during a period of great progress towards understanding the evolution of galaxies
over cosmic time, providing a deep insight into the distant Universe. The available
evidence is that the largest and most massive galaxies were largely in place by z=0.8, but
how different are galaxies at z=3 as compared to those at z=0? Has the HDF completed he
galaxy population census? Prof. Mark Dickinson, of the Space Telescope Scientific
Institute, answers in the following interview to questions like these and comments on the
HDF results at high redshifts.
The HDF has given us a direct
view of the Universe when it was significantly younger than it is today. How different are
galaxies at z=3 from those at z=0?
"There are interesting
similarities and differences. The galaxies which we observe at z=3 have a space density
comparable to that of L* galaxies today, and most interestingly they appear to cluster
together with comparable correlation strength as do bright galaxies locally. We find
"walls" of large scale structure at z=3 just as we do at z=0, and a similar
correlation length. On the other hand, the sizes and morphologies of the galaxies are
quite different than those of L* galaxies today they are smaller, and we do not see
forms which fit neatly into the classical Hubble Sequence of spirals and ellipticals. They
are also forming stars more rapidly than do typical, bright galaxies today. In many ways
their spectral properties are similar to those of present-day starburst galaxies. Their
clustering leads us to believe that these are the predecessors of todays massive
galaxies, but the evolutionary path from z=3 to z=0 is not yet clear."
The fact that galaxy
properties change with redshift provides strong support for a cosmological origin of
redshifts and for Big Bang cosmology, as opposed to non-standard cosmologies such as
Hoyles steady state cosmology. At what redshift does the homogeneity of the Universe
break down, i.e. how far back in time do we need to go to find a Universe in which galaxy
properties were clearly different than those we see nowadays?
"Certainly at z=1 (when
the Universe was somewhere between 1/2 and 1/3 its present age) the galaxy population was
substantially different than it is today, with a much greater global star formation rate,
and with many more luminous irregular galaxies present. There is reasonably good evidence
for evolution even in the last few billion years of cosmic history, e.g. out at z=0.3 or
0.4 e.g., the "Butcher-Oemler effect" in galaxy clusters, the greater
abundance of blue, star forming galaxies, and also apparently rapid evolution in the
ultraluminous infrared galaxy population. At the same time, out to z=1 we *do* find
"classical" Hubble sequence giant spirals and ellipticals in the universe, very
similar to those around us today."
After the success of the HDF,
what discoveries are expected of the HST in the field of galaxy formation and evolution?
What is the limit for HST? What will NGST provide?
"We now have good
pictures of the distant universe and a partial census of its galaxy population, but at
present our understanding of the formation and evolution of those galaxies is still fairly
rudimentary. The work now consists of "connecting the dots" i.e., of
drawing evolutionary connections between the galaxy populations we see at different
epochs. Much of this work will come from large ground-based surveys, especially those
which let us connect mass with light: e.g., via measurements of galaxy kinematics at high
redshift, or the study of galaxy clustering and its evolution. HST will continue to play
an important role, most especially through larger surveys that will be done when the
Advanced Camera for Surveys is installed late in 2000. We can expect significant new
developments from mid-infrared and sub-millimeter studies of distant galaxies, both from
space (SIRTF and eventually NGST) and with millimeter telescopes on the ground (SCUBA at
the JCMT now, and the MMA/LSA in the future). NGST should lead to tremendous advances in
our ability to study the spectral properties and kinematics of galaxies out to z=5, and
should be capable of seeing the first star forming objects in the universe at
substantially larger redshifts if they are not wholly obscured by dust."
In the past decade, an
amazing wealth of new information on distant galaxies has been gathered. In your view,
does the emerging picture of galaxy formation fit in a Cold Dark Matter cosmology? Do we
need a new cosmology, or can we amend CDM to make it fit the new data?
"At this point, the
basic paradigm of a Big Bang cosmology and structure formation by hierarchical clustering
(CDM or some variant thereon) seems surprisingly robust. Galaxy formation is probably
considerably more complex than has been modeled thus far by CDM-type models, and many of
the details will probably have to change (or at least, additional physics will have to be
incorporated in the future), but there are also many confirmations of the basic picture.
In particular, the existing data on galaxy clustering at z=3 is in excellent agreement
with the basic picture of biased galaxy formation in hierarchical models."
PROFILE
Born on November 24,
1962, in Connecticut (USA), MARK EVERETT DICKINSON was awarded his PhD in Astronomy by the
University of California in Berkeley (1994), with a thesis entitled "The Cluster
Environment of Distant Radio Galaxies" supervised by Hyron Spinrad.
He has ever since worked for
the Johns Hopkins University and the Space Telescope Science Institute, were he has been
an Assistant Astronomer since 1998.
His scientific interests are
focused on subjects such as optical, infrared and X-ray observational astronomy, objects
at high redschift, clusters of galaxies, large scale structure, QSO absorption line
systems, radio galaxies and galaxy evolution and observational cosmology. |