Comparing approximate methods for mock catalogues and covariance matrices II: power spectrum multipoles

Blot, L.; Crocce, Martin; Sefusatti, Emiliano; Lippich, Martha; Sánchez, Ariel G.; Colavincenzo, Manuel; Monaco, Pierluigi; Alvarez, Marcelo A.; Agrawal, Aniket; Avila, Santiago; Balaguera-Antolínez, A.; Bond, Richard; Codis, Sandrine; Dalla Vecchia, C.; Dorta, A.; Fosalba, Pablo; Izard, Albert; Kitaura, F.-Sh.; Pellejero-Ibanez, M.; Stein, George; Vakili, Mohammadjavad; Yepes, Gustavo
Bibliographical reference

Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, Volume 485, Issue 2, p.2806-2824

Advertised on:
Number of authors
IAC number of authors
Refereed citations
We study the accuracy of several approximate methods for gravitational dynamics in terms of halo power spectrum multipoles and their estimated covariance matrix. We propagate the differences in covariances into parameter constraints related to growth rate of structure, Alcock-Paczynski distortions, and biasing. We consider seven methods in three broad categories: algorithms that solve for halo density evolution deterministically using Lagrangian trajectories (ICE-COLA, PINOCCHIO, and PEAKPATCH), methods that rely on halo assignment schemes on to dark matter overdensities calibrated with a target N-body run (HALOGEN, PATCHY), and two standard assumptions about the full density probability distribution function (Gaussian and lognormal). We benchmark their performance against a set of three hundred N-body simulations, running similar sets of approximate simulations with matched initial conditions, for each method. We find that most methods reproduce the monopole to within 5{{ per cent}}, while residuals for the quadrupole are sometimes larger and scale dependent. The variance of the multipoles is typically reproduced within 10{{ per cent}}. Overall, we find that covariances built from approximate simulations yield errors on model parameters within 10{{ per cent}} of those from the N-body-based covariance.
Related projects
Project Image
Numerical Astrophysics: Galaxy Formation and Evolution

How galaxies formed and evolved through cosmic time is one of the key questions of modern astronomy and astrophysics. Cosmological time- and length-scales are so large that the evolution of individual galaxies cannot be directly observed. Only through numerical simulations can one follow the emergence of cosmic structures within the current

Dalla Vecchia
 The Invisible Scaffolding of Space
Cosmology with Large Scale Structure Probes

The Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) contains the statistical information about the early seeds of the structure formation in our Universe. Its natural counterpart in the local universe is the distribution of galaxies that arises as a result of gravitational growth of those primordial and small density fluctuations. The characterization of the